This post could also be called "Why Equipment Matters." For my office's beer and cookie exchange, I have to make 7 dozen cookies. Plus more for friends plus more to nibble on in the kitchen. Since I am not a baker, and do not enjoy the recipes required to be a good baker, I thought I'd try a shortbread, which I am told is the easiest cookie to perfect. Just butter, flour, sugar, perhaps a touch of vanilla. Thought I'd spruce it up with a little lavender and orange zest, for a little foodie flair. Over the last couple of weeks, I've tried a few different batches, and upon the advice of a friend (who's kind of a shortbread whiz) I decided this recipe was going to guide me throughout my afternoon of baking.
Since I'm cooking dozens of cookies, a pie dish (as suggested by Bon Apetit) just wouldn't do. I whipped out all of our baking gear, processed the crap out of almost four pounds of butter and even more flour, and prepped dough and pans for about 8 dozen cookies. After a few hours of processing and refrigerating and baking, I ended up with two wildly different results, as seen below (photographed with the wine I was drinking to ease my baking frustrations). One and a half batches came out in crumbles, the other two slid perfect out of the baking sheets. The difference: the successful batches were made in our heavy-duty non-stick metal pans. The failures (or shortbread chips) were baked in a thin metal hardly non-stick (though greased) pan.
On a stove top, it's relatively easy for me to adjust from one pot or pan to the next, to adapt to the kitchen materials you've been provided. Sure, it can change the results and the methods you have to use, but the likelihood is you can still make a sauce or some pasta. Baking, grrr, baking, why do you need such attention to detail?!?!
Good new is, shortbread chips still taste like butter and sugar, and that ain't all bad...